Discussion about this post

User's avatar
simeon's avatar

I feel a sympathetic ache with you all across the great water, overlaying the constant buzz of anxiety. And spasms of nausea kicked up by throbs of guilt. I renounced my US citizenship some years ago, the appointment of GW Bush by the so-called Supreme Court and invasion of Iraq being the straws that broke the camel's back. My reward for this empty symbolic gesture (following hefty "exit fees," and two quasi-interrogations at a US embassy) has been the obligation to vote for some bland, white-collar sneak thief in order to block Marine LePen every few years. And now we have an unelected , right-wing government here on the sufferance of Mme LePen's party. "All places shall be hell that is not heaven." Or at least a reasonable shot at it. Let's all pray for us all. Thank you for your nephew's piece. Two heavenly seconds of smiling.

Expand full comment
James Knutsen's avatar

As to the election, a recent political comment from a musician has really stayed with me. Over the weekend, I attended an excellent concert by the Vijay Iyer Trio (featuring Linda May Han Oh and Tyshawn Sorey) at the San Francisco Jazz Center. Iyer--and I think he was quoting someone, but I didn't catch whom--said to remember than when we vote, we are choosing whom we are going to fight. In other words, if you are for justice and peace, if you are for compassion (the title of this trio's recent album), forget the idea that the person you vote for is going to usher in a perfect world, or enact all the right policies. Assume that you will be in the opposition; assume that you will always be in a struggle with the political class. But do you want to be in a fight with someone who would be happy to burn the whole world down for their own aggrandizement, and who will do all they can to destroy every shred of progress that has been made in struggles of the past? Or with someone who has some significant level of commitment to norms of democracy, decency, respect, and truth? Does it suck to always be faced with a choice of the lesser of two evils? Yes. But considering the long sweep of human history and the options most people have faced, being able to make that choice, and then--one hopes!--to be able struggle against that lesser evil, is a high privilege. That's what I'm telling myself these days, anyway.

Expand full comment
72 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?