30 Comments
User's avatar
Foster Freed's avatar

You are right to resist summarizing the book's arguments; they need to be read and pondered in their entirety. And it's hardly a massive volume: unlike All Things are Full of Gods...which I continue to make my way through, one delightful chapter at a time! From my hardly unbiased perspective, both are worth the effort to read, ponder and inwardly digest! Blessings!

Robert Zhou's avatar

I for one believe that little Norwegian village really is an expression of divine love

Confluencer's avatar

I am Norwegian, I have been to Hell and I can in fact confirm this.

David Bentley Hart's avatar

It's true then: in a state of nature, all of us should go to Hell.

Robert Zhou's avatar

Finally, someone telling me to go to Hell without being rude about it. Gor-Gor would be pleased.

Robert Zhou's avatar

I’m sure you’d be a much better guide than Virgil

Momchil's avatar

While it is probably better for you not to post under the influence of THC (at least outside this Substack), do not, even for a moment, regret putting Ethan Muse in his place using the harshest possible words. His arguments are certainly vile and repulsive, but they are worded well enough to inflict irreversible psychological damage on more sensitive souls. For some people of his ilk, a good slap in the face can work better than any argument, but I am afraid he would enjoy it immensely.

Mistake Not...'s avatar

Ah, I was right! Where did Hart respond to him?

Mistake Not...'s avatar

I see. Thanks anyway.

michael robbins's avatar

As it happens I’m going to Vatican City today. I will attempt to set them straight.

Andrew McGaan's avatar

Dr. Hart: Thank you for posting these links. I read TASBS when it came out and it greatly moved me. I'm a lifelong Presbyterian (PC(USA)), so I suppose I'm "trained" to recoil when anyone trashes Calvin. Yet, truth be told, Calvin is rarely mentioned in PC(USA) churches in my experience. One minister confided, half jokingly, that he's bad for business. Maybe. Still, I was not exposed to Calvin's writings until I read them after I became a graduate theology student (a post-retirement pursuit). He's quite bracing. But I'm not sold on double predestination. (Side note: I have a short question to ask, if you're open to it. Is there a way to DM or email you privately?) Thanks, Andy

James Murnau's avatar

I'm a former Presbyterian (of sorts—I suppose I never officially joined up) and what I mainly got from reading Calvin was that attempts to tone him down on the subjects of predestination, church history, Hell, etc. don't do the man justice. He understood the logic of his own arguments and followed it inexorably. Now, I happen to think those airtight conclusions end up being an excellent argument against Calvinist theology (for the most part), but when I hear Reformed theologians trotting out the free will defense of Hell, I feel him spinning in his grave, and I'm right there with him.

Dano's avatar

Reformed academic: “you’re strawmanning!”

Calvin: “Did, I, stutter?” 🤨

George M's avatar

If there is anything to bring me out of a tragic agnosticism, it is your theological and metaphysical vision David. The problem of evil remains a stumbling block. Not a personal plug, but something I found recently here on Substack, which for me made universalism and the untold stretches of misery and suffering quite acute, was anyhumanever.com; one can choose a random human life (test one’s cosmic luck as it were; one presumes some science went into its development). Alas, I was a boy born in the Indus Valley in 794 CE, who died of dysentery as a newborn.

Matt Boulter's avatar

I just want to say that Piper is not *even* an actual Calvinist.

James Murnau's avatar

He also has surprising (if occasional) flashes of moral insight. This was a long time ago, but the stuff he wrote about the death of Trayvon Martin was moving and perceptive, showing a great deal of empathy for both Martin and his parents and an acute understand of the Christian duty to protect human life. When he isn't blinded by his Reformed Baptist theology, he can be almost prophetic. It's weird.

David Bentley Hart's avatar

Weird indeed. But a lot of Christians think of God in a way that makes him out to be their moral inferior.

James Murnau's avatar

"George Zimmerman should have left the gun in his truck because of the mere chance he could have killed a child with it, but God is off the hook for creating hundreds of millions of children as vessels of destruction" is certainly an odd way to do theology.

Hunter Coates's avatar

I’m gonna have to start doing this with my Grace Abounds. Thanks for the inspiration!

Kyle Page's avatar

Are there any books you'd recommend for further study on the topic of the intellectualist or rational model of freedom?

joel klepac's avatar

I thought TASBS was the summary of the argument?

Amory Lee Ewerdt's avatar

I saw you are going to publish a book with Quoir Press on Christian universalism. When can we expect that? You have helped my soul tremendously through your unashamed support of the non-contradictory love of God and I look forward to anything else you have to say about the matter.

Mistake Not...'s avatar

Sorry, are you referring to some response you left to the odious Ethan Muse? Where can I read it?

Joseph McHugh's avatar

Come now. Tell me you don't secretly hope for the existence of a place of eternal torment. For you know as I do that if such a place existed, our current President would be on the fast track.

David Bentley Hart's avatar

Actually, what I want is for him to be rescued from the Hell in which he's been trapped for his whole life, and that would entail him having to pass through the purgatorial fires of self-knowledge, mourning, and repentance.

Joseph McHugh's avatar

Well surely only an all powerful God could accomplish that!

Julian's avatar

Do you think the free will defense of Hell is semi-pelagian in essence?

David Bentley Hart's avatar

That wouldn't count against it for me. By the way, I prefer the term semi-Augustinian.