I have to admit that I wasn’t expecting a conversation between you and Rain Wilson. You are full of surprises, Mr. Hart, and simply awesome.

Expand full comment
Sep 16, 2022·edited Sep 16, 2022

Just The Avengers? Listen.

When are you finally going to address ‘60s and ‘70s Doctor Who? It’s the elephant in the room.

I cannot accept the accuracy of Roland in Moonlight for this reason. At no point in the text does he even mention Jon Pertwee. At no point do you state that the writing reached its peak when Robert Holmes was script editor. But I’ve been to your house many times and I know what goes on there.

(Or is this to be the subject of a sequel??)

Expand full comment

Ok, I feel like I might be in a dream.

Expand full comment

I see that some people here have expressed quite a lot of admiration and affection for the Baha'i Faith, even going as far as to admit that they could actually picture themselves converting to it in the future.

I understand why so many people are attracted to the Baha'i Faith when they first learn about it, especially people that identify as "liberals" or "progressives" in the current (and American) sense of these terms : being explicitly opposed to sexism, racism, nationalism, religious bigotry and anti-science attitudes, it is true that this religion has much to offer to such people.

However, please do consider these less widely known facts about the Baha'i Faith in order to get the bigger picture :

- Baha'u'llah defended the concept of the death penalty for two specific crimes : arson and murder.

If you are indeed a liberal/progressive, it seems that in order to be a "good" Baha'i, you are going to have to consider relinquishing an important part of what it usually means to be a liberal : opposition to the death penalty, under all or almost all circumstances.

Murder is to be punished by death... It is rather disturbing to see someone who taught that Jesus was a Manifestation of God (as the Baha'i Faith would put it) suddenly and radically reject the Nazarene's most fundamental ethical teaching, which is to *not* take revenge on anyone and to *never* resort to any kind of violence.

- Any Baha'i who openly disagrees with and/or criticises the official policies adopted by the governing body of the Faith, which is the Universal House of Justice, falls into the Covenant-Breaker category of people.

"Covenant-Breaker" is a Baha'i expression that can mean "heretic" or "apostate" and Covenant-Breakers are to be excommunicated and shunned by all Baha'is, including family members.

Furthermore, a Baha'i who refuses to stop frequenting a Covenant-Breaker is at risk of being considered a Covenant-Breaker himself.

If you happen to know anything at all about, say, the Jehovah's Witnesses, then you know that there's no difference between how the Witnesses treat their apostates and how Baha'is are traditionally expected (at least on paper) to treat theirs.

And obviously, this is nothing short of cult-like mentality, no need to sugarcoat it.

- "Practicing" homosexuals (and bisexuals, of course) are a notable exception to the Baha'i Faith's commitment to tolerance : while it is true that homosexuals are tolerated by virtue of their humanity and that they are even allowed to join the Baha'i Faith, Baha'u'llah forbade sodomy and his great grandson, Shoghi Effendi, the third head of the Faith, described homosexuality as "an affliction that should be overcome".

The Baha'i Faith teaches that instead of engaging in this "sinful" behaviour, homosexuals must consider remaining celibate for life - as if such a life would be anywhere near satisfying for the overwhelming majority of people.

It isn't like *only* the Baha'i Faith condemns homosexuality, of course (even most *buddhist* clergymen do actually condemn it as "sexual misconduct", at least in Southeast Asia), but here again, if you are indeed a "liberal" at heart, then it seems to me that in order to become a "good" Baha'i, there's much more you are going to have to change about your whole worldview than what you might have expected so far.

- While the Baha'i Faith claims to be opposed to sexism, none of the 9 members of the Baha'i Universal House of Justice, the single most important and influential Baha'i institution of all since it is the one that supervises the whole faith, may ever be a woman.

At the highest level of the Baha'i Faith, women have no say in, not in spiritual matters... Quite surprising, for a religion that repeatedly teaches that men and women are spiritually equal.

Furthermore, if you think that this state of things is reformable, you might want to reconsider : Abdu'l-Baha, eldest son of Baha'u'llah and head of the Baha'i Faith after his father's death, said "it will become clear, in the future, why this (male-only) restriction is in place".

More things could still be said, but I think that this is quite enough, already.

I mean, I do like many aspects of the Baha'i Faith and I do think *much* more highly of it than, say, evangelical protestantism, that wicked cult we call the Jehovah's Witnesses or that spectacularly stupid religion we call Mormonism (Mormonism, I mean... Words fail me), but still, I am not going to fall for this.

And neither should you, really.

Expand full comment

Your comments about a "progressive revelation" by God over time and about a widespread "prejudice against religions that are not old enough" have me wondering about how to best retitle the team blog that I administer which is currently called "Jesus and the Ancient Paths." Perhaps "Jesus and the Wise Paths" would be best? Much to ponder. Also excited to hear of your upcoming talk titled "Prisca Theologia: Revelation as Polyphony" at the upcoming conference on "Converging Wisdom? Questioning the Continued Relevance of the Perennial Philosophy" (October 2-4, 2022). Perhaps there will be more related to some of your thoughts on God's "progressive revelation" to us?

Expand full comment

Really looking forward to this one. The Baha’i community here in Northern CA has been incredibly welcoming to me at some of the interfaith gatherings I have attended. I’m thrilled to pass this along to a few friends here. Thanks for this one David.

Expand full comment

"Baha'i, baseball, Beatles."

Classic stuff. lol

Expand full comment

Listening to both of you, we feel that the spiritual dimension of existence is a reality !

Expand full comment

It was interesting to hear you mention your visit to Mount Athos and your experience there. I had been unaware. Do you write of that trip anywhere?

Expand full comment

A charming conversation and a good intro to a faith I knew very little about, even though I’ve visited the mentioned temple several times. The beach that’s by the temple is also lovely; Roland would surely appreciate it.

Expand full comment

You change (or already changed) your name on social media platforms to express more heat and protest for climate to be proper.

Expand full comment

I was not interested in this at all because of the celebrity of the guest, but instead because I have had a long-held curiosity about Baha'i ever since boyhood when I was told that my Great-Grandmother was a friend of a practitioner. This all (my memory and this podcast) sounded very good to me, so much so that I've been casually researching further throughout the day, going so far as to read some of the prayers aloud and chanting Alláh-u-Abhá 95 times. Very curious about this faith, and greatly grateful as to how it permits my affection for Christianity and Buddhism.

Expand full comment

Do you incorporates pantheistic ideas into your theology David?

Expand full comment

A very enjoyable and enlightening conversation. And I confess it was delightful to see someone finally get David’s goat.

Expand full comment

I recall the Jack in the Box in my hometown as a child in the 70's. However, as it was on the other side of town, my parents chose to be regulars (as much as money provided) at the local Yankee Doodle Dandy (fantastic fast-food chain in Chicagoland). At some point Jack in the Box ended up with an E. coli issue that resulted in their local demise. Yankee Doodle succumbed to an unfortunate demise as well (one that I still mourn) as their ownership decided to retreat from fast food restaurants. Thanks for the ride on the culinary way-back machine.

Expand full comment