54 Comments
User's avatar
Michael J. Sanem's avatar

David, this post filled me with so much joy. I felt like I was sitting next to you and your family at Christmas dinner. What a gift you are to us, to Christendom, and to the entire damn world (and cosmos). I pray and hope you are feeling better after your surgery; chronic pain is a beast I know well. Merry Christmas to you and yours. As I sit here with my dog Bruce in my lap, I can only feel gratitude for your gifts, and your witness.

Expand full comment
David Bentley Hart's avatar

Thanks, you're very kind.

Expand full comment
B. C. Taylor's avatar

Merry Christmas to you and yours DBH & to everyone else who may be reading this. Thank you for your engaging and stimulating articles; it's a pleasure to live with them as a weekly feature. Here's to your return to health and happiness in the New Year.

(p.s. I can't help but sympathise with our man with the winter allergies since I'm currently nursing my own time-honoured and traditional festive head-cold and/or flu. But I'm not allowing my spirits to be dampened by this since it wouldn't feel like Christmas without it. Sancte Guinefortis, ora pro mihi)

Expand full comment
David Bentley Hart's avatar

Technically, that should be 'ora pro me', but Guinefort is boundlessly magnanimous and would never trouble himself over trifles of grammar.

Expand full comment
B. C. Taylor's avatar

From so noble and elevated a creature as he I would gladly take instruction on grammar or otherwise and never bridle or sulk.

Expand full comment
Matthew Mazza's avatar

Merry Christmas! Here’s to a healthy and happy 2025. God bless you and yours and thank you for all that you do

Expand full comment
Rob Grayson's avatar

From England, where nobody knows whence the appellation "Boxing Day" derives but we happily still call it that anyway, I wish you a most merry Christmastide and an abundance of good things in 2025.

Expand full comment
David Bentley Hart's avatar

Whenever the source of a custom is lost to public memory, the thing to do is invent a genetic myth that can turn it into a commercial opportunity. Just as the invention of Scottish tartan lore created at once a mythical taxonomy of clan patterns and a market for kilts and scarves and such for tourists eager to bring home some 'authentic' symbol of their Scottish forebears' clan identities, so Boxing Day could be made into a time of year when those same tourists are encouraged to engage in the 'ancient British custom' of buying expensive boxes for all your beloved friends and family.

Expand full comment
Rob Grayson's avatar

You should be in marketing 😉

Expand full comment
David Bentley Hart's avatar

Yeah, I missed my calling.

Expand full comment
D.W. Frauenfelder's avatar

Merry Christmas to you, sir., and many good wishes for a healthy 2025. I take it as a sign you are recovering that you are back to writing engaging posts. Thank you and God bless you.

Expand full comment
David Bentley Hart's avatar

Many thanks. I hope I am recovering, so prayers are still welcome.

Expand full comment
Alana K. Asby's avatar

What a merry jest about St. Guinefort! It reminds me of all the Christmasy jesting and laughter in 'Gawain and the Green Knight.'

Expand full comment
Troy's avatar

As a medievalist, I should mention that one of the most famous examples of the Annales approach to history is Jean-Claude Schmitt's "Le Saint lévrier. Guinefort, guérisseur d'enfants depuis le XIIIe siècle."

Expand full comment
David Bentley Hart's avatar

A fine book.

Expand full comment
Benjamin Woollard's avatar

Merry Christmas, David! I hadn’t heard of St. Guinefort, but I’m delighted and shall direct my veneration accordingly. It occurs to me that the story you shared in your last post of the pilgrim passing off a dog’s tooth as a relic, only to witness miracles, could just as well be attributed to the sanctity (much more common in that species) of the animal in question.

Expand full comment
David Bentley Hart's avatar

You know, I had just had that very thought when your comment arrived. Synchronicity... Great minds... and so forth.

Expand full comment
Momchil's avatar

Happy Christmas, Dr. Hart! May you and your loved ones enjoy a very healthy, joyful, and, above all, peaceful 2025. A good start on the path to the last wish would be not annexing Greenland and the Panama Canal.

The Godfather reference would have made me spill my tea, had I been drinking one at the time of reading it.

Your contempt for fox hunting may put you on a collision course with your dear friend John Milbank. I couldn’t comprehend how such a great and kind man could tolerate that barbaric practice until I realized that he would not give up a single Albionian tradition (unless it was of Puritan origin, of course).

Expand full comment
David Bentley Hart's avatar

I think that if John ever really witnessed the death of a fox he would be wracked with fellow feeling for the little creature. Sometimes an anxiety over the disintegration of Britain perhaps makes him jealous of everything traditionally British.

I promise not to annex either Greenland or Panama in the coming year, but I have no influence over the ochre imbecile.

Expand full comment
Troy's avatar

He has his sights set on Canada, too.

Expand full comment
David Bentley Hart's avatar

Luckily he’s too stupid to know how to find it.

Expand full comment
Edgar's avatar

Well, my wife got me Prisms, Veils as a surprise gift - so there is really not much I could ask for.

As someone who is really bad at short stories, this book gives me something to strive for.

I hope your recovery is going well!

Expand full comment
B. Nyeholt's avatar

For those interested, the Lilith (1964) film mentioned here is deeply interesting and beautiful. Hadn’t heard of it before reading this post. Aesthetic rapture and the nature of insanity are prominent themes.

Expand full comment
iphps@yahoo.com's avatar

David, if you consult this very recent article https://www.pillarcatholic.com/p/pope-francis-announced-an-equipollent you'll see that Rome very much still accepts canonization by acclamation though not with that name. Warm regards from a friendly Catholic. ....Ian.

Expand full comment
Steven King's avatar

Wishing you a Beary Merry Christmas indeed, DBH (づ ◕‿◕ )づ

P.s.: Stocking Bear is a very cute teddy bear 💙🙏 — Friends are nice :)

Expand full comment
Annette Samuel's avatar

Wouldn't dream of taking my tree down before Twelfth night ....

Expand full comment
David Bentley Hart's avatar

You are not far from the Kingdom.

Expand full comment
Bret van den Brink's avatar

§8 was awfully clever. The penny was in the air with the epigraph from “The Hound of Heaven” and the penny dropped with the illumination and Latin text at the bottom. One wonders if there was perhaps an implicit pun of Fido and fidelis.

What a delightful way to be introduced to St. Guinefort—bravo!

Expand full comment
Bret van den Brink's avatar

The delightful irony, of course, is that the villain of the tale was himself a domini canis by the name of his order.

Expand full comment
David Bentley Hart's avatar

Not that the domini canes have any real right to that high distinction.

Expand full comment
michael röbbins's avatar

This is my least favorite time of year. Besides the cold & dark, there are my winter allergies to contend with. People say, "Why don't you move to California?" Because I have tenure. Academic jobs are dear these days. Also California is full of Californians. Anyway, a happy Boxing Day to those you who aren't dreaming of June.

Expand full comment
David Bentley Hart's avatar

You're such a bundle of joy, Michael. I would like some update on your bursitis while you're at it.

Expand full comment
michael röbbins's avatar

OK, I'll send you a text. Several texts.

Expand full comment
Steven King's avatar

Reminds me that "a burden shared is a burden halved"—you're blessed to have a very kind and wonderful friend, my dear Michael! Merry Christmas to you too :) 💙

Expand full comment
michael röbbins's avatar

Let's not go overboard.

Expand full comment
Steven King's avatar

💙 Haha ;), :).

Expand full comment
Steven King's avatar

Prayers and Blessings to you Michael 💙 Hope yours get better in time 🙏 , my friend

(づ ◕‿◕ )づ

At a young age, I grew up with really bad nose allergies, I carried small boxes of tissues to primary school in my tiny backpack as my average sneeze time was around 1-2 minutes (lasting hours), I remember my face/nose congestion was so bad that kids always thought I was about to cry/was sad, Haha. Fortunately, I Thank God 💙 that it's way, way better now, after moving away from my hometown to where I'm residing currently:

I woke up to some sniffles today, but felt a lot better after a warm shower—Will keep you in my prayers, dear Michael 💙🫶

Expand full comment